TOT MAKER
HOMEMADE TATER TOTS FROM SCRATCH
HOMEMADE TATER TOTS FROM SCRATCH
HOW TO MAKE
THE PERFECT TATER TOT
THE TATER TOT MAKER
MR RUSSET
THE TATER
TOT MAKER FAQ
Do I have to pre-cook the potatoes?
Yes, you can microwave, bake, or boil the potato. See the recipe or instructions pages for details.
Do I need flour or binders?
No. Potatoes naturally stick together once cooked.
What’s the best way to get crispy homemade tater tots?
For the crispiest tots, use russet potatoes, let them cool before molding, and cook them in 375°F oil. The Tot Maker creates uniform shapes that cook evenly, helping every tot crisp perfectly. Remember, the dryer the potato (as when baked) the faster they brown and crisp up. Try different ways, you get different textures experiment away !!
Can I air fry the tots?
Absolutely. Air fry at 400°F for 12–15 minutes until golden.
What oils work best for frying tater tots?
Any high-heat oils like canola, vegetable, peanut- beef tallow works great as well AND adds flavor!
Can I make spicy tater tots ?
YES ! We recommend adding salt and pepper to them and any spice you like- garlic powder, cayenne pepper, Cajun seasoning…anything you prefer !
Why did my tots fall apart?
Tots will only fall apart if potato too dry after cooking OR you did not pack into tot maker tight enough.
Does the Tot Maker work better than hand-shaping tater tots?
Absolutely. Hand-forming tots leads to uneven shapes that fall apart or cook inconsistently. The Tot Maker compresses the potato evenly and creates a consistent shape, which results in better texture and more professional-looking tots. Thats how tot maker was born- we were tired of hand forming LOL !!
What’s the best tater tot recipe to use with the Tot Maker?
The best tater tot recipe in our opinion uses microwaved/ then wrapped russet potatoes, cooled and seasoned with salt, pepper, and a pinch of garlic powder. Press them into the Tot Maker for perfect shape, then fry at 375°F for 2-4 minutes until golden (watch them close). This method gives you crispy homemade tots without additives.
Can I mix onions into the potatoes when making the tots ?
Yes ! Just know that the onions will brown faster but it adds a rich onion flavor !
Are homemade tater tots easy to make ?
YES ! Watch the videos, it is fast, easy, and kids can form them while you fry them !
How many tater tots can I get from one potato ?
You can get about 10 tater tots from one potato depending on potato size.
How do I get the perfect tater tot texture ?
The ‘perfect’ texture is a personal preference. Some people like a fluffy soft interior with that golden crunchy exterior and some like their tots more crunchy and a more firm almost chunky interior (like frozen tots. The key is how you cook the potato. For a firmer/chunky/crispy feel, bake the potato. Baking also makes the tots richer, more intense in potato flavor. For a perfect golden crispy tot with a softer interior, microwave the potato 5 minutes, wrap in foil, and rest 40 minutes. We prefer this method as it makes tots easiest to form. Try both ways !

What method is best to cook tater tots ?
We feel the best is frying the tots in beef tallow as #1. The second best is a typical high smoking point oil. These methods result in the crispy golden texture people expect and all tots on site were cooked this way.
Can we sell Tot Maker in our retail store or online ?
To inquire about retail purchasing please email us at totmaker1@gmail.com , and we will be happy to get you setup !
